scintilla of evidence rule

scintilla of evidence rule
/sintila av evadans/ A spark of evidence. A metaphorical expression to describe a very insignificant or trifling item or particle of evidence; used in the statement of the common-law rule that if there is any evidence at all in a case, even a mere scintilla, tending to support a material issue, the case cannot be taken from the jury, but must be left to their decision. The "scintilla evidence rule" requires that if there is even a scintilla of evidence presented to support the nonmoving party's position, summary judgment should not be granted. Chiniche v. Smith, Ala., 374 So.2d 872, 873.
With regard to precluding summary judgment for defendant, "scintilla rule" requires only that the evidence, or reasonable inferences therefrom, furnish a mere gleam, glimmer, spark, the least bit, the smallest trace, in support of plaintiffs complaint. Wilson v. Liberty Nat. Life Ins. Co., Ala., 331 So.2d 617, 619
Any material evidence that, if true, would tend to establish issue in mind of reasonable juror. Something of substance and relevant consequence and not vague, uncertain, or irrelevant matter not carrying quality of proof or having fitness to induce conviction. WigginL ton's Adm'r v. Louisville Ry. Co., 256 Ky. 287, 75 S.W.2d 1046, 1051.
Courts differ as to what constitutes a "scintilla," and some courts do not accept the rule. For example, it has been held that while the cogency of evidence is not dependent on its quantity, if the party with the burden of proof has introduced only a scintilla of evidence on an essential element of his case, a judge may direct a verdict against him. Such evidence is inadequate as a matter of law. It has also been held that it is the duty of trial court to instruct a verdict, though there is slight testimony, if its probative force is so weak that it only raises suspicion of existence of facts sought to be established, since such testimony falls short of being "evidence". Texas Pacific Coal & Oil Co. v. Wells, Tex.Civ.App., 151 S.W.2d 927, 929

Black's law dictionary. . 1990.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать реферат

Look at other dictionaries:

  • substantial evidence rule — Such evidence that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support a conclusion. It is that quality of evidence necessary for a court to affirm a decision of an administrative board. Under the substantial evidence rule, reviewing courts… …   Black's law dictionary

  • evidence — Any species of proof, or probative matter, legally presented at the trial of an issue, by the act of the parties and through the medium of witnesses, records, documents, exhibits, concrete objects, etc., for the purpose of inducing belief in the… …   Black's law dictionary

  • evidence — Any species of proof, or probative matter, legally presented at the trial of an issue, by the act of the parties and through the medium of witnesses, records, documents, exhibits, concrete objects, etc., for the purpose of inducing belief in the… …   Black's law dictionary

  • evidence — ev·i·dence 1 / e və dəns, ˌdens/ n [Medieval Latin evidentia, from Latin, that which is obvious, from evident evidens clear, obvious, from e out of, from + videns, present participle of videre to see]: something that furnishes or tends to furnish …   Law dictionary

  • scintilla rule — The rule, now very generally rejected or abandoned in most jurisdictions, that a verdict is never directed for a party if there is any evidence, slight though it may be, in favor of the other party. 53 Am J1st Trial § 356. The rule that if there… …   Ballentine's law dictionary

  • no evidence — Under the rule that the court may render judgment non obstante veredicto if directed verdict would have been proper, the term no evidence does not mean literally no evidence at all; no evidence comprehends those situations wherein by the… …   Black's law dictionary

  • no evidence — Under the rule that the court may render judgment non obstante veredicto if directed verdict would have been proper, the term no evidence does not mean literally no evidence at all; no evidence comprehends those situations wherein by the… …   Black's law dictionary

  • NLRB v. Columbian Enameling & Stamping Co. — NLRB v. Columbian Enameling Stamping Co. Supreme Court of the United States Argued January 11 12, 193 …   Wikipedia

  • Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda link allegations timeline — The Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda timeline below list allegations of meetings, all but one now discounted, denied or disproven by the United States Government, between al Qaeda members and members of Saddam Hussein s government, as well as other… …   Wikipedia

  • Guantanamo Bay detention camp — The Guantanamo Bay Detention Camp is a controversial [ [http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/3754238.stm Guantanamo controversy rumbles on] ] United States detention center operated by Joint Task Force Guantanamo since 2002 in Guantanamo Bay …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”